如果盟軍飛行員在二戰中被德國士兵俘虜,他的命運會如何?他會因為情報而受到審問和酷刑嗎?

在戰爭的前半段,有許多德國空軍以善意和尊重對待被擊落的盟軍飛行員的例子。飛行員道格拉斯·巴德和鮑勃·斯坦福·塔克在1941 年和1942 年被擊落後,都受到了德國王牌飛行員阿道夫·加蘭的招待和熱情款待。英國飛行員、雙腿截肢者巴德被擊落並被俘後,德國人甚至向英國皇家空軍發出訊號:說巴德很安全。他們說他是一名戰俘,但在跳傘時失去了假腿,並要求英國皇家空軍為他提供一條備用假腿,他們照做了。

巴德(抽著煙鬥)受到加蘭(中左)的招待。

一般來說,如果西方盟軍機組人員被俘,他們將被移交給德國空軍,德國空軍會審問他們幾天,但通常會遵守《日內瓦公約》的規則。作為戰俘的盟軍機組人員的生活條件並不舒適,食物也往往相當有限。幸運的是,這些人有時可以接觸到紅十字會的包裹,這可能在戰爭結束時讓他們得以生存。與蘇聯戰俘不同,95% 的西方盟軍戰俘在戰爭中倖存下來。平均而言,一週內死亡的蘇聯囚犯比整個戰爭期間所有其他西方盟國囚犯的總和還要多。

隨著戰爭的進展和空襲的加劇,德國的情況日益惡化。戈培爾在他的定期廣播中鼓勵德國平民將法律掌握在自己手中,並對他所謂的「恐怖飛行者」或恐怖傳單的爆炸事件進行報復。在呂塞爾海姆,美因茨和法蘭克福之間的一個地方,八名美國機組人員列隊穿過城鎮中心。附近的歐寶工廠前一天晚上遭到英國皇家空軍的轟炸,囚​​犯們遭到兩名德國婦女的攻擊,她們向她們丟磚頭。他們的守衛袖手旁觀,什麼也沒做。工廠裡的男性工人也加入其中,用鐵棍毆打機組人員。當囚犯流血受傷時,一名防空典獄長用手槍射擊了每個人的頭部。六槍後,他的彈藥耗盡,無法消滅剩下的受震蕩的飛行員。八具屍體被裝上一輛手推車,運往墓地。當空襲警報響起時,綁架者跑向避難所,兩名還活著的機組人員設法爬走並逃脫。

1944 年 8 月,168 名盟軍機組人員被認定為“恐怖飛行人員”,並被送往布痕瓦爾德 (Buchenwald)集中營。他們是來自英國、美國、澳洲、加拿大、紐西蘭和牙買加的傳單。在乘坐運牛車進行了五天的旅行後,飛行員被剃光了頭,被迫赤腳工作並在露天睡覺。如果不是被正在檢查附近空襲受損情況的德國空軍軍官發現,他們很可能都會被勞累致死。1944 年 10 月,機組人員被轉移到德國空軍戰俘營,並因此在戰爭中倖存下來。

也許針對盟軍機組人員的最臭名昭著的行為是處決 50 名從 Stalagluft III 戰俘營逃亡的人,這在流行文化中被稱為「大逃亡」。這些謀殺是希特勒直接下令的,而不是當地發起的。一般來說,規則是,如果盟軍機組人員被移交給德國空軍,他們很可能會受到符合日內瓦公約的待遇。然而,危險的部分是當它們落入蓋世太保、黨衛軍或當地憤怒平民團體等其他納粹組織手中時。

宋卡府的個人資料照片
新增評論...
喬斯林·哈達克 (Jocelyn Hardacre) 的個人資料照片

主演《大逃亡》的英國演員唐納德普萊森斯在希特勒戰爭中是一名依良心拒服兵役的人,直到倫敦被轟炸。隨後他加入英國皇家空軍,擔任機組人員。他被擊落,蓋世太保拔掉了他的指甲。

喬恩·特魯 (Jon Trew) 的個人資料照片
彼得·利文斯通的個人資料照片

扮演集中營指揮官的演員是演員中唯一真正的戰俘——在他的例子中,他在英國的集中營裡。

喬恩·特魯 (Jon Trew) 的個人資料照片
威廉·帕特森的個人資料照片

是的,他在戰爭中倖存下來,我在某處讀到囚犯證明了他對戰俘的良好和公平對待

喬恩·特魯 (Jon Trew) 的個人資料照片
彼得·利文斯通的個人資料照片
喬恩·特魯 (Jon Trew) 的個人資料照片

我讀過蓋伊沃特斯的書《真正的大逃亡》,我會推薦這本書。顯然,集中營的指揮官和他的副手都是仁慈的人,他們適當地對待囚犯。顯然,他們警告囚犯領導人,如果他們透過大規模越獄給納粹領導層帶來尷尬,可能會發生什麼事。

喬恩·特魯 (Jon Trew) 的個人資料照片

謝謝喬斯林。我不知道。我原本以為這可能是都市傳說,但我查了一下,這是真的。

伊麗莎白·波斯特的個人資料照片

很好的答案,感謝您的寫作

喬恩·特魯 (Jon Trew) 的個人資料照片

For the first half of the war there were many examples of the Luftwaffe treating downed allied pilots with kindness and respect. Pilots Douglas Bader and Bob Stanford Tuck were both given dinner and treated well by the German Ace Adolf Galland after they were shot down in 1941 and 1942. After the British pilot and double amputee Bader was shot down and captured the Germans even signalled the RAF to say that Bader was safe. They said he was a POW but had lost his artificial leg while baling out and asked the RAF to drop a spare for him, which they did.

Bader (smoking a pipe) being entertained by Galland (centre left).

Generally if western allied air crew were captured they would be handed over to the Luftwaffe who would question them for a few days but generally kept to the rules of the Geneva Convention. Conditions for allied aircrew as prisoners were not comfortable and food was often quite limited. Fortunately these men sometimes had access to Red Cross parcels which towards the end of the war were probably responsible for keeping them alive. Unlike Soviet prisoners, 95% of western allied POW’s survived the war. On average more Soviet prisoners died in a week than all the other western allies prisoners put together in the whole of the war.

As the war progressed and air raids increased in ferocity, conditions in Germany deteriorated. Goebels in his regular radio broadcasts encourage German civilians to take the law into their own hands and get revenge for the bombing on what he called “terrorflieger” or terror flyers. In Rüsselheim a place between Mainz and Frankfurt eight American aircrew were marched through the middle of the town. The nearby Opel factory had been bombed by the RAF the night before and the prisoners were attacked by two German women who threw bricks at them. Their guards stood by and did nothing. They were joined by male factory workers who joined in beating the aircrew using iron bars. As the prisoners lay bleeding and injured, an air raid warden shot each one in the head with a pistol. After six shots he ran out of ammunition and could not finish off the remaining concussed flyers. The eight bodies were loaded onto a cart and taken to the cemetery. When an air raid alert sounded they captors ran for the shelter the two crew members who were still alive managed to crawl away and escape.

In August 1944 168 Allied aircrew were identified as “terrorfliegers” and sent to the Buchenwald concentration camp. They were flyers from Britain, the United States, Australia, Canada, New Zealand and Jamaica. After a five day journey in a cattle truck the airmen had their heads shaven and were forced to work barefoot and sleep in the open air. It is likely they would have all been worked to death if they had not been spotted by Luftwaffe officers who were inspecting nearby air raid damage. In October of 1944 the aircrew were transferred to a Luftwaffe POW camp and as a result survived the war.

Perhaps the most notorious act against Allied air crew was the execution of 50 escapers from the POW camp Stalagluft III known in popular culture as ‘The Great Escape’. These murders were ordered directly by Hitler rather than local initiatives. Generally the rule was if allied air crew were handed over to the Luftwaffe they were likely to be treated in line with the Geneva convention. However the risky part was when they were in the hands of other Nazi organisations such as the Gestapo, the SS or local groups of enraged civilians.

Profile photo for Songkhla
Add a comment...
Profile photo for Jocelyn Hardacre

The British actor Donald Pleasance, who starred in the Great Escape, was a conscientious objector in the Hitler war, until London was bombed. He then joined the RAF, serving as aircrew. He was shot down and Gestapo tore out his fingernails.

Profile photo for Jon Trew
Profile photo for Peter Livingstone

The actor who played the camp Commandant was the only other member of the cast to have been an actual POW - in his case he was in a camp in the UK.

Profile photo for Jon Trew
Profile photo for William Patterson

Yes he survived the war, and I read somewhere the prisoners gave evidence to his good and fair treatment of the POWs

Profile photo for Jon Trew
Profile photo for Peter Livingstone
Profile photo for Jon Trew

Ive read Guy Walters book The Real Great Escape which I would recommend. It is clear that the camp commandant and his deputy were humane men who treated prisoners appropriately. It is clear that they warned prisoners leaders what might happen if they caused embarrassment to the Nazi leadership through mass escapes.

Profile photo for Jon Trew

Thanks Jocelyn. I didn't know that. I initialy thought that might be an urban legend but I looked it up and it is true.

Profile photo for Elisabeth Post

Great answer, thanks for writing

Profile photo for Jon Trew
Profile photo for Adam Fayed
 · 
Follow
I have found something straightforward works wonders. That is startsing early! As Newton said, objects in motion tend to stay in motion. The same is true for achieving a business or life goal. The image below (Source Jamesclear) illustrates the point. We all have experienced how difficult it is to get mo…
Icon for Europe History & Culture
Profile photo for Dima Vorobiev
Dima Vorobiev
 · 7h
TLDR: Something famous from an old aristocratic lineage or anything posh that sounds like Western royalty. LONGER ANSWER When you are part of a colonization project, last names that indicate an aristocratic provenance are very prestigious. If you have a choice, go for a posh one. Hoi polloi In Russia, we…
Profile photo for Li Shejian
 · 
Follow
This is Gaza This is Iraq searched on the same platform And this is Urumqi, the capital of Xinjiang Here is the city of Ili close to the border with China, and the natural scenic area near Ili, the last tear of the Atlantic Ocean. This is Kashgar City in southern Xinjiang, which retains the local tradit…
Profile photo for Torben Retboll
 · 
Follow
The answer to this question is yes: Some Jews were living in Berlin during world war two and most of them survived the war. How could this happen? A special group of Jews: they were married to German aryans before 1933. Since they were married to German citizens who were regarded as aryans, Nazi Germany…
Profile photo for Yao Ming
 · 
Following
If you really want to deeply understand the conflict you have to study the two religions. Judaism and Islam. They both claim the same origins. Abraham, they both claim, is the the father of them all. Judaism was the Jewish religion created roughly 3,200 years ago. They attribute it to their founder A…
Jira Software, Atlassian
See how Jira helps 100,000+ companies ship with confidence and sanity. Sign up for free today!
Sign Up
Profile photo for Aya Shawn
 · 
Follow
First I want to say that I am not a racist. But I believe that the economic development of East and Southeast Asian countries has a lot to do with culture. We will find a phenomenon. All developed and nearly developed countries in this region have a common characteristic: connection with Chinese cultu…
Profile photo for Jānis Šnepsts
 · 
Follow

歐洲歷史文化 · 
訂閱
迪瑪·沃羅比耶夫 (Dima Vorobiev) 的個人資料照片
迪馬·沃羅比耶夫
 · 7小時
TLDR:來自古老貴族血統的著名物品或任何聽起來像西方皇室的豪華物品。 長答案 當你參與殖民計畫時,表示貴族出身的姓氏是非常有聲望的。如果您有選擇,請選擇豪華的。Hoi polloi 在俄羅斯,我們...
這是加薩 這是同平台搜尋到的伊拉克 這是新疆首府烏魯木齊 這裡是靠近中國邊境的伊犁市,也是伊犁附近的自然風景區,大西洋的最後一滴眼淚。 這是南疆的喀什市,保留著當地的傳統…
Torben Retboll 的個人資料照片
這個問題的答案是肯定的:第二次世界大戰期間,一些猶太人生活在柏林,其中大多數人在戰爭中倖存下來。怎麼會發生這種事?猶太人的一個特殊群體:他們在1933年之前與德國雅利安人結婚。由於他們與被視為雅利安人的德國公民結婚,納粹德國…
姚明的個人檔案照片
 · 
下列的
如果你真的想深入了解衝突,你必須研究這兩種宗教。猶太教和伊斯蘭教。他們都聲稱具有相同的起源。他們都聲稱亞伯拉罕是他們所有人的父親。 猶太教是大約 3,200 年前創建的猶太宗教。他們將其歸因於他們的創始人A …
排名第一的軟體開發工具是什麼?
阿雅·肖恩 (Aya Shawn) 的個人資料照片
 · 
跟隨
首先我想說我不是種族主義者。 但我認為東亞、東南亞國家的經濟發展與文化有很大關係。我們會發現一個現象。該地區所有已開發國家和近發達國家都有一個共同特徵:與中國文化的聯繫…
Jānis Šnepsts 的個人資料照片

留言

這個網誌中的熱門文章

北越故事:童年、從軍、戰場、戰後、晚年【平民眼中的戰爭:從香蕉湯到尿袋人生】

投稿:戰爭不是劇本:從香蕉湯到尿袋人生