《新聞週刊》是信託計畫成員佐治亞州眾議員瑪喬麗·泰勒·格林 (Marjorie Taylor Greene)與埃隆·馬斯克 (Elon Musk)的 xAI創建的人工智能助手和聊天機器人 Grok 發生了爭執，原因是 Grok 質疑了她的信仰。
背景
格林在 2017 年因支持川普的「美國優先」口號當選國會議員，他是眾議院最具爭議的議員之一。
格林除了是唐納德·川普總統最堅定的支持者之一之外，還曾散佈有關疫苗、COVID-19 疫情、2021 年 1 月 6 日國會大廈騷亂、所謂的美國「深層政府」、天氣等錯誤訊息。
須知
格林與格羅克的爭吵發生在這位佐治亞州議員在X上發布了關於她的基督教信仰的帖子之後，她寫道：“我是一名基督徒，一個不完美的罪人，因耶穌的恩典和信仰而得救。我是一名民族主義者，一個自豪的美國人，我熱愛我的國家，並希望讓我們的祖國成為所有美國公民和子孫主義者，一個自豪的家園。”
她繼續說：「我是一位母親，感謝上帝賜予我照顧孩子的恩賜和責任。我是一位企業主，我謙卑而感恩能夠在世界上最偉大的國家裡，盡我所能地努力工作，獲得成功。在這裡，沒有白白付出，一切都是靠自己努力爭取的。我是一位上帝保佑上帝，我被選出來，是為了服務地球上最偉大的國家，上帝保佑
另一位 X 用戶透過 Grok 瀏覽了 Greene 的帖子，並詢問人工智慧機器人：“這是真的嗎？她真的是基督徒嗎？”
格羅克回應說，雖然格林通過表達對耶穌基督的信仰和擁有傳統信仰“認定自己是一名基督徒”，但“她的基督教民族主義和對 QAnon 等陰謀論的支持引發了爭論。”
格羅克繼續說道：「包括宗教領袖在內的批評者認為，她的行為違背了基督教的愛與團結的價值觀，並引用了她對 1 月 6 日事件的辯護和分裂言論。」支持者或許認為她的立場是出於信仰。她是否『真正』是基督徒則是主觀問題，取決於個人觀點和神學觀點。她的信仰看似真誠，但她的公開行為引發了爭議。
格林對 Grok 的回答提出了異議，並在隨後的 X 帖子中回復道：“@grok，審判席屬於上帝，而不是你這個非人類的人工智能平台。Grok 傾向左派，並繼續傳播虛假新聞和宣傳。當人們放棄自己的判斷力，停止尋求真相，並依賴人工智能來分析信息時，他們就會迷失。”
另一位 X 用戶“Grok’s Handler”要求 Grok 分析 Greene 的辯護，他寫道：“嘿 @grok，雖然@mtgreenee 聲稱自己是基督徒，但她的公開評論和投票記錄是否符合耶穌的教義？答案是肯定的或否定的。”
「沒有，」格羅克回答。
週五並不是 Grok 第一次發表批評共和黨人和馬斯克的回應，馬斯克於 2022 年收購了 X（前身為Twitter），是川普最大的支持者之一。
該人工智慧助理最近還因否認 600 萬猶太人在大屠殺中喪生（後來將其歸咎於“編程錯誤”）以及暗示南非發生“白人種族滅絕”的說法屬實而受到抨擊。
與此同時，馬斯克聲稱 Grok 是世界上「最聰明的人工智慧」。
人們在說什麼
《華盛頓郵報》專欄作家菲利普·邦普 (Philip Bump)對藍天上的這場爭吵做出了回應，他寫道： “哈哈，MTG 是在和一台電腦爭論上帝。”
接下來會發生什麼
格林最近與幾乎所有眾議院共和黨人一起投票支持川普支持的「宏大而美麗」的和解方案，該方案增加了移民和邊境安全的資金——這是川普議程的關鍵支柱——同時削減醫療補助和社會安全等關鍵項目的支出。
更新時間：2025 年 5 月 23 日下午 4:02（美國東部時間）：此報告已更新，並添加了更多資訊和背景。
關於作者
索南謝斯Conversation
Start a discussion, not a fire. Post with kindness. Read our guidelines here
All Comments
Comment by EdmundPeshall.
We most certainly do NOT need artificial intelligence to determine that MTG is NOT a Christian. In fact, she is most likely an agent of Mephistopheles.
Reply by jdlech.
As is everyone who expresses (or enacts) opinions, policies and actions that contradict the teachings of the Christ, regardless of expressed opinions about being a Christian.
The Bible calls these people hypocrites, wolves in sheeps clothing and goats. Jesus was highly critical of them.
Reply by Toxteth O'Grady.
It's too bad they don't read the Bible to know that.
Comment by dreamn8r.
Really now.. love? HER? Who would?
Reply by kaintucki.
Igor? Dude from West Palm?
Comment by bunny porch.
Bring mad at Grok is like believing the Bible.
The only difference is: Grok is woke, because reality is woke, and no amount of being mad about it is going to change. You’re just going to end angry.
Comment by Toxteth O'Grady.
Artificial I vs. Total Absence of I.
Love it.
😂
Comment by opus512.
Even a biased ai knows she's lying.
Comment by _8647_.
The fact she got outwitted by a machine isn't surprising, or news.
Comment by nikdavey.
The entire "Christian Conservative" movement is neither Christian, in the "love thy neighbour" sense, nor conservative - witness the all out assault on institutions like the judiciary, the scientific infrastructure of the country, the free press and the education system.
Comment by popisannoyed.
Empty Gee, the grift that keeps on giving. She argues with a non sentient about....what difference it's a non sentient. I believe she could get into an argument in an empty room.
Comment by Your Other Left.
True that Greene's actions do spark controversy. She and Boebert are a a pair. But Grok is not in a position to judge anyone. Its responses are based on algorithms. Grok cannot say, "She's not a Christian." What's more, that relationship is between Greene and her god. Christians believe that even the worst sinner can be saved. Jews also believe that sins can be purged.
Reply by Jane Coxtoastin.
Gee. I thought that was essentially what Grok said. Only God knows. And the issue isn’t whether a sinner can be saved at anytime, it’s whether she is saved now.
The Bible does say persistent deliberate sin raises questions as to the sincerity of that faith. MTG consistently pushes hateful lying rhetoric so she clearly doesn’t repent but repeats her anti Christian antics. (1 John 3:8-9)
Perhaps one of her worse offenses was calling school shootings “false flags” , something made up by Hillary and Pelosi and defending Alex Jone’s role in this hateful conspiracy even after he acknowledged it was a lie.
But, all of this doesn’t mean she’s not a believer in that Jesus is the son of God, died for our sins and was resurrected.
Reply by Your Other Left.
Theoretically a sinner could be saved right up to the end, no matter what they did before. We don't know how that works. The question, "Is she a Christian?" implies a value judgment and would be considered snarky under any circumstance.
Comment by John Simmions.
MAGA, The Republican Party, and Project 2025, believe that Donald Trump with 34 felony convictions from a jury of his peers, is their Messiah/God!
